Friday, February 28, 2014

Interviews with Artists

This past week I had the pleasure to chat with CSO Music Director Laureate, Paavo Järvi when he was in town to conduct a concert at Music Hall. When asked his opinion on whether or not Schubert existed in the shadow of Beethoven, he responded, “Everyone existed in Beethoven’s shadow.”


Maestro Järvi described Beethoven as a god-like figure that most composers didn’t dare to tread near. “In awe” of what he achieved with his Ninth Symphony, most composers who came after Beethoven felt “insecure” about the symphony genre. Paavo then went on to mention how Schubert wrote his “Great” Symphony (mentioned in yesterday's post) attempting to make it in the likeness of Beethoven’s first. He knew he could never accomplish what Beethoven was able to provide listeners with his Symphony No. 9 but thought that if he could compose something “worthy” of Beethoven’s first (one of his lesser-known works) he would be satisfied.


What do you think? In your opinion, has anyone ever accomplished what Beethoven did with his Symphony No. 9?

 

Thursday, February 27, 2014

Finding His Voice: Schubert's "Great" Symphony

On Monday we discussed Schubert existing in the shadow of Beethoven’s legacy. Today I would like to discuss one of Schubert’s exceptional works and get your opinion on how it holds up next to the works of Beethoven.
 

Schubert’s Symphony No. 9 in C Major “Great” was never performed during the composer’s lifetime. It was not until ten years following Schubert’s death that Robert Schumann uncovered the manuscripts and insisted that it make a public appearance that very year. Though many composers felt it best to avoid composing symphonies in fear of being compared to Beethoven’s symphonic repertoire, Schumann praised the “Great” Symphony saying that in it Schubert successfully created his own approach to writing a symphony.


In his Symphony No. 9, Schubert blends the Romantic lyricism found in his lieder with Beethoven’s drama. The first movement begins with a slow, chorale introduction in the horn section before moving into an allegro. Portions of this chorale come back later in the movement.


Schubert’s Symphony No. 9 in C Major “Great” will be tonight’s 6 o’clock symphony. Tune in to 90.9 WGUC and then let me know if you think Schubert was able to find his own voice in this piece or if he still remains in Beethoven’s shadow.

Monday, February 24, 2014

Franz Schubert: A Life in the Shadows

Continuing on with our jealousy theme, this week I would like to ponder the relationship between two great Romantic composers: Ludwig van Beethoven and Franz Schubert. Twenty-seven years Beethoven’s minor, Schubert grew up in Vienna with obvious knowledge of the elder composer’s great success and contribution to the music world. Establishing an eternal legacy in his ability to reach new heights in composition, Beethoven created somewhat of a “shadow” for those composers to follow in coming years. Like many, Schubert believed that in order to be successful, he must attempt to say something new within the forms Beethoven had already established. The young composer visited Beethoven on several occasions, requesting that this gifted man give him advice related to his work.
 

Though we may look at Schubert as a pillar in our musical canon, during his lifetime, he never quite saw the extent of his success that really blossomed many years following his death. Even the poet Goethe, whom Schubert held in high regard, ignored the poor composer’s settings of his poetry until after he had passed away.


On March 26, 1827, Schubert’s works were performed in a private concert. Though people seemed to enjoy his work, the great Beethoven breathed his last that very day, most likely turning many eyes away from the aspiring composer. Schubert was then asked to bear a torch at Beethoven’s funeral. Did Schubert perhaps feel tinges of jealousy toward Beethoven? Or did he simply aspire to learn from his greatness and carve his own musical path? This we do not know for certain but it does seem evident that Schubert suffered a rather unfortunate life, never living to see how great his work would become.
 

Schubert died only two years following Beethoven at the young age of 31. Ironically, he was laid to rest beside Beethoven in a Vienna graveyard. Does this signify Schubert as Beethoven’s equal? Or perhaps as a means of reminding him that he will forever remain in the shadows?